A MOTHER accused a young man of ‘lying’ in court after a judge had directed a jury to find him not guilty of causing her daughter’s death by dangerous driving.
Gary O’Donnell, (22), had pleaded not guilty to causing the death of his ex-girlfriend, Kym Harley (19), in a single vehicle crash close to her home at Dreenan, Ballybofey, in October 14, 2014.
Mr O’Donnell, from Steeple View, Dunwiley, Stranorlar, told Gardaí in an interview that he had swerved to avoid a collision with two dogs, a black labrador and a beagle.
He also admitted he may have been going faster than the 50 kmh speed limit, but didn’t believe it was “serious speed”.
There were emotional scenes in Letterkenny Courthouse on Wednesday evening when Judge John O’Hagan directed the jury to find Mr O’Donnell not guilty on the grounds of insufficient evidence.
Members of the Harley family, including her father Martin, a Donegal Fine Gael County Councillor, were visibly upset at the back of the court. As the case concluded, Kym’s mother, Denise, approached Mr O’Donnell saying: “You’re a liar, she never loved you, she was never getting back with you. You killed her.”
Earlier in the two-day hearing at Letterkenny Circuit Criminal Court, evidence was heard that the defendant’s Nissan Almera struck a ditch and ended up on its roof. Kym, who had turned 19 days earlier, died at the scene.
Mr O’Donnell claimed the couple had split up after an 18-month relationship but had got back together the evening before the 4.15am crash, which occurred just a few hundred metres from her home.
In his evidence to the jury on Wednesday, garda forensic collision expert, Sergeant John McFadden, said speed had been the cause of the crash. He ruled out weather, the condition of the road and the condition of the vehicle as contributory factors in the incident which took place in a rural residential area in a 50kmh speed limit zone.
Sgt McFadden said he conducted six tests on the estimated speed of the Nissan as it went around a bend before the crash.
The lowest estimated speed of the vehicle from those tests was 94.3 kmh. Sergeant McFadden said he also drove the route in test conditions and concluded the ‘critical’ speed at which the bend could be driven was 78 kmh.
“I wouldn’t have pushed it any further than that,” he said.
The sergeant said tyre marks showed the back right hand side of the vehicle began to spin around anti-clockwise as Mr O’Donnell began to lose control of the car. Further on, he said, Mr O’Donnell had “completely lost control”.
Marks left on the road from the tyres had shown this, he claimed.
Under cross-examination from Jonathan Kilfeather, SC, Sgt McFadden said Mr O’Donnell was driving at “94.3kmh or more” during the incident.
He said he used the lowest possible speed to give benefit to the driver.
“The vehicle was travelling too fast. He could not steer,” said Sgt McFadden.
The car swung around, hit a ditch and the vehicle flipped up and onto its roof. The car left initial marks for 46.3m, he said, and Mr O’Donnell righted the car which then skidded into the ditch, leaving a second set of skid marks.
Mr Kilfeather said the suggestion that Mr O’Donnell recovered the vehicle in the following 7.5m before the wheels were locked in a braking action – without leaving any marks on the road – was ‘ridiculous’.
Dr Mark Jordan, a forensic collision expert called by the defence, said it was his view that the 46.3m long marks left on the road may not have been left by Mr O’Donnell’s car at all.
He said the gap of 7.5m between the first marks and the second set of road marks led him to conclude that it was “more than likely left by another vehicle”.
Dr Jordan said the fish-tail manoeuvre, which the prosecution said took place, would have left another set of marks on the road, but no marks were found.
However Patricia McLaughlin, prosecuting put it to Dr Jordan that Mr O’Donnell had admitted to Gardaí at the scene that he had lost control of his car and it had slid sideways during the incident.
Dr Jordan accepted that the second set of straight tyre marks, which he believed Mr O’Donnell had made on the road, were inconsistent with that admission, saying the marks would not have been straight.
Judge John O’Hagan accepted an application from Mr Kilfeather to withdraw the case from the jury on grounds of insufficient evidence. He instructed the jury to return a ‘not guilty’ verdict.
Receive quality journalism wherever you are, on any device. Keep up to date from the comfort of your own home with a digital subscription.
Any time | Any place | Anywhere